Before Kelly Reilly became a household name as the fierce Beth Dutton in Yellowstone, she was already making waves in Hollywood with her remarkable versatility. Nine years before her iconic role in the hit TV series, Reilly had a breakthrough year in 2009, starring in three distinct period films that showcased her exceptional range and acting prowess. These roles not only solidified her reputation as a talented actress but also set the stage for her eventual rise to stardom.
A Star in the Making: Reilly’s 2009 Triumph
In 2009, Reilly delivered standout performances in three period dramas, each set in vastly different historical contexts. These films—Sherlock Holmes, Triage, and Me and Orson Welles—highlighted her ability to embody complex characters across diverse eras, earning her critical acclaim and paving the way for her future success.
Sherlock Holmes: A Quiet Strength
In Guy Ritchie’s reimagining of Arthur Conan Doyle’s classic tales, Reilly played Mary Morstan, the love interest of Dr. Watson (Jude Law). While the film centered on the dynamic between Sherlock Holmes (Robert Downey Jr.) and Watson, Reilly’s portrayal of Mary added emotional depth to the story. Her character, often seen as a stabilizing force amidst the chaos, showcased Reilly’s ability to bring subtlety and strength to even supporting roles. Mary’s quiet resilience and moments of vulnerability hinted at the emotional complexity Reilly would later bring to Beth Dutton.
Triage: A Heartbreaking Portrayal
Set against the backdrop of the 1988 Kurdish conflict, Triage explored the psychological toll of war on soldiers and their families. Reilly played Diane, the pregnant wife of a photojournalist (Jamie Sives) who returns home traumatized. Her performance was a masterclass in restraint, conveying grief and hope through quiet gestures and nuanced expressions. Diane’s struggle to maintain normalcy in the face of uncertainty resonated deeply, proving Reilly’s ability to anchor emotionally charged narratives.
Me and Orson Welles: Confidence and Grace
In Richard Linklater’s Me and Orson Welles, Reilly portrayed Muriel Brassler, a seasoned actress in Orson Welles’ Mercury Theatre. Though not the central character, Reilly’s Muriel exuded confidence and poise, standing out in a male-dominated world. Her portrayal of a woman who knows her worth and navigates the challenges of her profession with grace mirrored the assertiveness Reilly would later bring to Beth Dutton. This role further cemented her ability to elevate even secondary characters into memorable performances.
From Period Films to Yellowstone: A Seamless Transition
Reilly’s work in these period films laid the foundation for her portrayal of Beth Dutton. The emotional depth, quiet strength, and resilience she demonstrated in Triage, Sherlock Holmes, and Me and Orson Welles are echoed in Beth’s fierce yet vulnerable persona. Whether navigating the chaos of the Dutton family or standing her ground in a male-dominated world, Reilly’s Beth is a testament to her ability to bring complexity and authenticity to her roles.
A Journey of Versatility
Kelly Reilly’s breakout year in 2009 was a turning point in her career, showcasing her versatility and setting the stage for her iconic role in Yellowstone. Her performances in Sherlock Holmes, Triage, and Me and Orson Welles not only highlighted her talent but also demonstrated her ability to excel in diverse genres and settings. As fans continue to celebrate her portrayal of Beth Dutton, it’s worth revisiting the roles that shaped her journey and solidified her place as one of Hollywood’s most compelling actresses.
Reilly’s story is a reminder that success in Hollywood often comes from a combination of talent, hard work, and the ability to embrace diverse challenges a lesson she continues to embody with every role she takes on.